Menu

Critique Service

How to Request a Critique  –  Fees  –  Testimonials

As part of our aim to promote and inspire writers, and to help bring their work up to publication standard, Fish Publishing offers a high quality Critique Service. Our editors take great care to ensure that critiques are useful and constructive. This valuable service has benefited many writers, (see testimonials). 

Critique Service is for:

Short Stories (up to 5,000 words)
Short Memoir (up to 4,000 words)
Flash Fiction (up to 300 words)
Poetry (up to 400 words)

You can avail of this Critique Service at any time (with or without entering a Contest).  
Request a critique either by post or online. The online option is slightly cheaper.

 

Please Note: The word limit for the Flash Fiction Contest and Poetry Contest is 300.

For longer work, collections, see Editorial Consultancy

For writers who require on-going support and direction, see Mentoring Service.

For screenwriting see Screenwriting Editorial Consultancy

 

 

 

How to Request a Critique

Online: login with the green button below, then select the appropriate options.

 

By Post:

Send your work with your contact details, plus the appropriate fee to: Fish Publishing, Durrus, Bantry, Co Cork, Ireland.
You will receive your critique by email unless you request otherwise.
Cheques should be made payable to Fish Publishing and be in your own currency. Currency Converter

 

 

Fees: Critique Service 


Short Story
(up to 5,000 words)
Online: €55 (about £47, US$57)
Post: €58

Short Memoir (up to 4,000 words)
Online: €55 (about £47, US$57)
Post: €58

Flash Fiction Story (up to 300 words)
Online: €38 (about £32, US$40)
Post: €40

Poem (up to 400 words)
Online: €38 (about £32, US$40)
Post: €40

Currency Converter

 

Testimonials: Critique Service 

After being a runner up in a recent contest for FISH publishing I wanted to understand what nuances and details I was missing to be a finalist; I enlisted one of their editors for a critique. The assessment I received was detailed, analytical, and thought provoking.  Adhering to their suggestions for the first chapter of my memoir it was selected by Roxane Gay as runner up for the coveted non-fiction Iowa Review Prize. The FISH editorial team is exemplary. Andes Hruby

This is possibly the most constructive and detailed critique I’ve ever had. I will be recommending you guys to anyone who asks! Anna Nazarova-Evans

I sincerely enjoyed the critiques that Ms. Holmes reviewed on one of my poems. Michael Galligan

The comments with regard to my work have been as valuable as gold.

Just want to let you know how much I appreciate the feedback on both my pieces. This feedback has highlighted the exact elements I have had some difficulty with myself and given me re-assuring comments. I am deeply grateful and will approach you again for feedback. But now, I’m off to develop my reflective voice…

Thanks for another excellent job.

Many thanks for your Edit of the above and I’ve taken your excellent advice, thoughts, and suggestions on board. Much re-writing required methinks, and am already reworking the stories.

Thank you so much Clem, it is indeed very helpful. Just the description of it as a “descent into hell” has cleared up my thinking and I feel re-inspired, and there’s lots more to absorb as well.

Thank you so much for the critique. I consider it extremely valuable feedback.

I have found your comments very helpful indeed on the flash fiction course and was wondering whether you offered critiques on stories of other lengths. I have used the Fish critique service before which is of course very professional. However I think there is an art to getting the message across and I like your approach. Your introductory remarks are helpful and your zooming in and adding comments on the text is great. These are comments that I take on board not only for that story but for my creative writing as a whole. So many thanks to you for your courtesy and kindness, and many thanks to your editor for the insightful, diplomatically worded, and helpful comments. I can imagine how challenging it must be to provide truthful, diplomatic, and if possible also encouraging comments to unpublished writers. I truly appreciate his or her time and effort.

I just wanted to thank you for the critique. I found it very helpful actually. So, much appreciated.

I am not sure who provided this feedback by I am very grateful for the insight provided. It is a rare treat to have someone read one’s work so closely.

Fish Publishing, Durrus, Bantry, Co. Cork, Ireland

COPYRIGHT 2016 FISH PUBLISHING